Kevin Costner Opens Up About Finding Love After Years of the Single Life

Photo by Jeff Kravitz // FilmMagic

When it comes to his love life, Kevin Costner has been through it all. He’s dealt with falling in love, heartbreak, deception, infidelity, and divorce. These days, however, it seems as though the actor has finally found the woman who has caused him to change his ways. While he once embraced the single life and struggled to remain faithful to any of his romantic encounters, Costner is now quite the family man with a loving wife and several children. Things weren’t always this way, though, Costner went through quite the journey to get to where he is today.

Savoring The Single Life

It’s been a wild ride for Kevin Costner. After going through a rough divorce right when his career was taking off, the Dances with Wolves actor spent years trying to find that one special someone.

(Left) Pinterest // @countryliving | (Right) Pinterest // @tomallmon

Costner spent most of the ’90s enjoying the single life, dating girl after girl with little time in between, ultimately earning himself a reputation as an A-list womanizer. Now, however, it seems that the Hollywood actor has changed his ways.

A One-Woman Man

Kevin Costner’s wild and unpredictable lifestyle has led him to become the subject of numerous tabloid headlines and Hollywood rumors. While he has never been shy when it comes to admitting his wrongdoings, Costner has kept quiet regarding certain aspects of his personal life.

Twitter // @K_Costner_Page

Believe it or not, before all the fame and fortune, Costner was once a one-woman man, happily married to his college sweetheart. However, with success came the temptations of being a celebrity, some of which he simply couldn’t resist…

His First Love

Kevin Costner first met Cindy Silva while the two were college students attending California State University at Fullerton. “She was beautiful, she was sweet, she was smarter than me,” said Costner in a 1989 interview.

Pinterest // @tomallmon

“She represented everything about women that I like.” Costner and Cindy tied the knot in 1978. For several years, the newlyweds were happy together and even had three kids together – Annie, Lily, and Joe. Unfortunately, their relationship wouldn’t stay this way for very long.

Calling It Quits

Not long after Silva worked together with Costner on his critically-acclaimed film Dances With Wolves, rumors began to emerge regarding infidelity on Costner’s side. The two did what they could to keep their marriage afloat, but eventually decided to call it quits.

Pinterest // @tomallmon

In 1994, Cindy and Kevin announced their divorce in a statement which read, “After 16 years together, we are ending our marriage. We have amicably resolved all issues regarding our children and financial affairs and a full marital settlement has been reached.”

A Lone Wolf

Many fans were shocked to learn that Costner’s marriage was coming to an end, but to friends and coworkers, the divorce was no surprise.

Twitter // @K_Costner_Page

“I have a big thirst. A big taste for things…. I hate the fact that I’ve lived by somebody else’s rules and I’ve somehow missed out on something,” said Costner in an interview in 1987. Looking back now, it’s easy to see that the Dances With Wolves actor was hinting that his marriage with Cindy had gone sour.

A Taste Of What Was To Come

For some celebrities, fame comes at a price. Just before going public with the divorce, Costner opened up in an interview with the Daily News. “The temptations are pretty strong—and there’s a hungry world out there waiting for you to fall.”

Pinterest // @rhiannonyoung54

“So you can’t even dabble without paying a huge price. I try to conduct my life with a certain amount of dignity and discretion—but marriage is a hard, hard gig.” Costner’s love life would only become more complicated with time.

A Secret Scandal

Coming off his divorce, Costner had a brief fling with a woman named Bridget Rooney. Rooney is known for being a member of the family that owns and operates the Pittsburgh Steelers NFL franchise in addition to her 2011 movie, Zombie or Not Zombie.

Pinterest // @celebritybody

Their relationship was said to last from 1995 until 1996. Although Costner would have preferred to keep his affair with Rooney as quiet as possible and out of the media’s eye, a scandal would eventually surface, drastically changing his plans.

Bridget’s Secret Revealed

In 1996, Bridget Rooney gave birth to a son, and Costner’s fourth child, Liam Costner. According to reports and rumors, Costner’s relationship with his fourth child was rather strained early on. In fact, Costner only recognized that little Liam was his son after Rooney demanded he take a paternity test.

Twitter // @iKaptainKush

Once Costner’s paternity test results came back, he opened up a trust fund for the boy. One source told People magazine that Costner visited Liam “occasionally but not on a regular basis.”

Extra-Marital Rumors

While it was never officially confirmed, Costner reportedly engaged in an extra-marital affair with Halle Berry back in 1989, while he was still married to Cindy Silva.

Twitter // @movie_gal_10

At the time of the rumored fling, Berry had just begun her career as an actress, appearing in 12 episodes of Living Dolls. Neither Costner not Berry have commented on the rumors, but the A-list stars remain friends to this day and have been spotted together in public on various occasions.

Something In Common

Just a year after Costner’s rumored affair with Halle Berry, the Field of Dreams star came face-to-face with yet another tabloid headline regarding a brief rumored romance, this time with Michelle Pfeiffer, the actress who rose to prominence after her portrayal of Elvira Hancock in the 1983 classic film, Scarface.

(Left) Instagram // @michellepfeifferofficial | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

It turns out that Michelle Pfeiffer and Halle Berry have something in common aside from their rumored Costner flings- they both portrayed Cat Woman at some point in their respective careers.

A Piece Of The Pie

Another woman who claims to have gone on a few dates with Costner is Bobbie Jean Brown, the actress, model, and former beauty pageant contestant most famous for being the star of Warrant’s music video for their song “Cherry Pie.”

Pinterest // @80ssbaby

Brown revealed all the juicy details about her fling with Costner in her tell-all memoir titled “Dirty Rocker Boys: Love And Lust On The Sunset Strip.”

Kiss And Tell

Bobbie Jean Brown wasn’t the only celebrity to share some personal details about a low-key relationship with Kevin Costner. Peggy Trentini did the same in her memoir titled “Once Upon A Star: Celebrity Kiss And Tell Stories.”

Instagram // @shannonleetweedsimmons

Trentini rose to fame as a model and actress in the 1980s and 1990s. Since releasing her book, she has left the spotlight to focus on her career in real estate.

Aphrodite Draws Him In

Back in 1993, one year before Costner finalized his divorce with Cindy Silva, he was rumored to have engaged in yet another extra-marital affair with Mira Sorvino.

(Left) Instagram // @mirasorvino | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

Sorvino is an actress who became famous after her award-winning performance in Mighty Aphrodite, a 1995 romantic comedy film directed by Woody Allen. Back when she was rumored to have gotten together with Costner, Sorvino was still a relatively unknown, with just a few film credits on her acting resume.

On The Rebound

Holly Sampson, an actress and model who also goes by the names Nicolette Foster, Andrea Michaels, and Zoe, claims that she had a brief relationship with Kevin Costner in 1994, the same year that Costner divorced his first wife.

Pinterest // @dirks0465

After appearing in episodes of shows like Fred Savage’s The Wonder Years, My Two Dads, Beauty and the Beast, and Matlock, Sampson went on to pursue a career as an adult actress, appearing in titles like Lady Chatterly’s Stories, Thrills, and Bedtime Stories.

Courting A Supermodel

Costner was rumored to have had a fling with Naomi Campbell at some point during the mid-1990s. Campbell started her career at the age of 15 and quickly became one of the most recognizable names and faces in the world of modeling.

Instagram // @naomi

She has been engaged to Adam Clayton, the bassist for the band U2, as well as Flavio Briatore, a Formula One race car driver. Recently, Campbell has been rumored to be in a relationship with Louis C. Camilleri, a multimillionaire from Malta.

He Had No Alibi

Another one of Kevin Costner’s rumored flings was with Karin Reznack, an actress and screenwriter known for her work on films in the late 1980s such as Her Alibi and Clara’s Heart.

Instagram // @jesusantoniochavezacevedo

Following her rumored brief relationship with Costner, Reznack would go on to marry famous film director John Byrum in the late ’90s. While no one can confirm whether Costner and Reznack truly did get together, we’re not surprised that such rumors emerged given Costner’s colorful romantic history.

Defending An Ex

In 2006, Costner found himself in the midst of a scandal after being accused of lewd behavior while receiving a massage at a five-star hotel in 2004. One of Costner’s exes, Birgit Cunningham, chimed in to publicly support him.

(Left) Instagram // @birgitcunningham1111 | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

She issued a statement, saying, “Kevin is very romantic and tender, he would never do anything so vulgar… He really is Mr. Perfect, squeaky clean, if a little naive when it comes to realizing the effect he has on girls.”

Spotted With Angie

Back in 1995, Kevin Costner was spotted on a dinner date with Angie Everhart, a former actress and model who has appeared in numerous Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issues in addition to a 2000 issue of Playboy magazine.

Instagram // @angieeverhart1

Just before Costner was seen canoodling with the stunning redhead, rumors had emerged regarding his attempts to reconcile with his ex-wife Cindy. Not long after her rumored romance with Costner, Everhart tied the knot with actor, comedian, and singer-songwriter Ashley Hamilton.

A Fling With Monica

In 2001, Kevin Costner shared the big screen with Courteney Cox in the action adventure crime film 3000 Miles to Graceland.

(Left) Instagram // @courteneycoxofficial | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

Six years prior to the film’s release, however, Costner was linked to the star most famous for her portrayal of Monica Geller in Friends for a much different reason. According to inside sources, the two briefly dated back in 1995. Interestingly enough, Cox married David Arquette, another actor who appeared in 3000 Miles to Graceland, in 1999.

He Dated The First American Supermodel

Apparently, 1995 was a busy year in the love life of Kevin Costner. In August, the Field of Dreams star was believed to have had a romantic encounter with Cheryl Tiegs, the American fashion designer and model considered to be “the first American supermodel.”

Instagram // @christiebrinkley

That same year, Tiegs launched her “Cheryl Tiegs Sportswear” collection. She will always be best known for her multiple appearances on the cover of the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue, as well as TIME magazine.

Rifken Jr. Roughs Him Up

In another wild urban legend, Costner was rumored to have nearly ruined Cal Ripken Jr.’s record-breaking consecutive games streak after becoming romantically involved with Cal’s wife while staying at his home.

(Left) Pinterest // @phillipb717 | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

According to the story, Costner, who has portrayed baseball players in several films and had become close friends with Ripken Jr., was caught red-handed and was roughed up by the Hall-of-Famer on the spot. Ripken was so upset over the incident that the Baltimore Orioles canceled the upcoming game due to an “electrical failure.”

He Couldn’t Escape The Spotlight

In another 1995 romance, Kevin Costner was spotted on multiple occasions hitting the town with the American journalist, author, and television host Joan Lunden. Lunden was most famous for her role co-hosting ABC’s Good Morning America between 1980 and 1997.

Instagram // @joanlunden

Unfortunately, their relationship was cut short as the result of the relentless and overbearing attention from media sources. At the time, Costner was in the middle of promoting his film Waterworld, so the press was naturally curious about his personal life.

Putting The Charm On

Costner reportedly pulled out all the stops on their first date. “He got this yacht and we sailed around New York Harbor and had dinner,” said Lunden.

(Left) Instagram // @joanlunden | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

“It was quite romantic and quite beautiful. When he first walked on the boat and smiled at me… and said, ‘Boy, I’ve waited so long to meet you,’ I almost fell over.” Sadly, Costner’s charm wasn’t enough. “I think Kevin and I would have dated longer had it not been for the unbelievable press focus on us,” explained Lunden.

The Spark Of Hope

By 1996, it seemed as if Costner was ready to leave the single life behind and settle down in a more stable situation. That year, he started dating Australian businesswoman, television host, model, and actress Elle Macpherson.

(Left) Twitter // @AmirAlhaj_ph | (Right) Twitter // @AmirAlhaj_ph

The two moved quickly in their relationship and began living together within a matter of months. “I feel I have met my equal with this beautiful, talented, funny and lovely person,” said Costner. Unfortunately, their relationship would end before the year mark.

Rebound Round Two

Just after Costner and Elle Macpherson went their separate ways, he was rumored to have been romantically tied to Carla Bruni, an Italian-French singer-songwriter and former model.

Instagram // @carlabruniofficial

As one of the world’s first supermodels, Bruni has also been known to date famous men such as Mick Jagger, and Eric Clapton. While it may have appeared that Costner was ready to settle down in a serious relationship, another short fling would prove that old habits die hard…

Keeping It Low Key

In 1997, Kevin Costner was coming off two successful films. He had been nominated for a Golden Globe Award for his performance in 1996’s Tin Cup, and would soon receive another nomination in the form of a Saturn Award for his 1997 film The Postman.

Pinterest // @elizabeth23apr

That same year, he met news anchor and former Miss America winner Tawny Little. Their discreet relationship only lasted from 1997-1998. Little had previously dated men such as Ron Silver and Burt Reynolds.

An A-List Scandal

Kevin Costner has certainly seen his fair share of tabloid headlines. One rumor from 1999 claims that Costner had a brief romantic encounter with his co-star, Kelly Preston, while the two were working on the film For the Love of the Game.

(Left) Instagram // @therealkellypreston | (Right) Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

According to the National Enquirer, Travolta was “furious” over the allegations. Neither Costner nor Preston, who was married to actor John Travolta at the time, have addressed the rumors. Preston and Travolta remain happily married to this day. But things would soon change for Costner.

The One?

Kevin Costner had been on a seemingly endless search for love ever since his divorce in 1994. Then, he crossed paths with Christine Baumgartner, a stunning, much younger model and handbag designer whom he’d met several years prior while practicing on a golf course for his role in Tin Cup.

Shutterstock // Tinseltown

Costner had no idea what would transpire. “When I met Christine, I wasn’t prepared to be in love again,” says Costner. Only time would tell if the Dances With Wolves actor would change his ways…

Going Through A Rough Patch

Costner himself admitted that his love life was all over the place after his divorce from Cindy. “I was like the classic single guy — who do I love this week, who next week?” said the Dances With Wolves actor.

Twitter // @magstrology

When he began dating Christine, however, everything changed. Costner, a man who once considered himself a free spirit, had finally learned to love again. Unfortunately, Costner wasn’t quite ready to commit to having kids with Christine, and the couple briefly split up in 2002.

He Was Afraid

After being thrown back into the single life, Costner realized that breaking up with Christine was a terrible mistake. “Fear kept me from marrying Christine,” says Costner. “[She] wanted a child, but I was afraid I couldn’t be an effective father.”

Shutterstock // Featureflash Photo Agency

After dating for four years, “I woke up and thought, ‘Am I going to lose a beautiful woman who is willing to be with me to my very last breath because I am afraid to say yes to a child?’ That’s all it took.”

Taking The Plunge

Costner eventually came to his senses and returned to Christine. The couple tied the knot in September of 2004, saying “I do” in a private ceremony held at Costner’s estate in Aspen, Colorado in front of 300 close friends and family members.

Twitter // @edwereddie

This would be Christine’s first marriage and Costner’s second. His new bride was hopeful that he’d stay faithful, but only time would tell if the Field of Dreams star had truly changed his ways.

A Father Once Again

Costner and Baumgartner spent the first three years of their marriage enjoying an empty nest, but in May 2007, everything changed with the birth of their first son, Cayden. Suddenly it seemed as if Costner disappeared from the spotlight.

Pinterest // @lderrough

In reality, Costner was still working, but taking more time to focus on his side projects, like touring with his band and investing in a centrifuge machine. Most importantly, Costner took a break from acting in major motion pictures to focus on raising his family.

A Full House

Following the birth of Cayden in 2007, Costner and Baumgartner were blessed with two more kids- Hayes, born in 2009, and Grace, born in 2010. Costner opened up about life as a father in a 2011 interview.

Shutterstock // Tinseltown

“…They’re really good children,” explains Costner, “and I see them making steps every day, and the one thing I pray for in life is not success but being able to raise my children and that nothing happens to me in the next 20 years.”

Turning Over A New Leaf

“I want it to be me who tells them about the secrets, the beauty, the treachery and everything that is in life. I don’t want them to learn from someone else,” said Costner in an interview conducted in 2011.

Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

Baumgartner was thrilled to see that her new husband was so committed to his new family. It seemed as if he had truly turned over a new leaf compared to the father he once was with his previous children.

A Changed Man

In a 2007 interview with Good Housekeeping, Costner stated that he has “always been really close to my girls,” making it clear, however, that he doesn’t pick favorites. “All of my kids are showered with love,” explained Costner.

Shutterstock // Lucky Team Studio

Who would have thought that the man who once embraced a wild Hollywood single-guy lifestyle would have such a knack for fatherhood? These days, Costner would much rather brag about his kids’ accomplishments than engage in the shenanigans of his younger years.

Back On The Big Screen

After spending some time focusing on family, Costner eventually returned to making movies in 2013, playing Jonathan Kent in Man of Steel.

Instagram // @kevincostnermodernwest

“I won’t make a movie unless I have the ability to do it the way I want, so I hold my breath for a very long time,” explained Costner. “At this point in my life, I don’t want to make a movie I don’t want to make or one that somehow gets manipulated in a way I don’t feel comfortable with.”

“Rewarded My Whole Life”

Costner’s first real love was acting, but to him, fatherhood is much more fulfilling. “Movies are magic, and they’ve always been magic to me,” explains Costner.

Shutterstock // s_bukley

“You get to play heroes in the movies, but there’s a moment in time where you’re just a father and you get to go home. I have played two roles in my life, one I get paid to do, which is the movies, and the other one is being a father, for which I’ll be rewarded my whole life.”

Happily Ever After

“Sometimes you learn the thing you’re most afraid of will save your life,” said Costner. Now, the man who was once frightened of commitment is happily married to Christine, a woman nearly 20 years younger than him.

Shutterstock // Ovidiu Hrubaru

The couple have been married for 18 years, with three very happy kids. Costner now embraces being a loving husband and father. And as for Christine, the blonde bombshell couldn’t be happier to share the rest of her life with the man of her dreams!